Which raises a final question: if nothing is expected of religion in the first place, no Truth, no Salvation, why adhere to it at all? There are far better ways to socialize.

Image AI-generated
On June 26, the “Religious Liberty Commission” appointed by Donald Trump presented a 224-page draft report in the Oval Office. The message that has since circulated through U.S. media: the separation of church and state is a “legal error.” Twelve recommendations are intended to correct this alleged mistake — ranging from abolishing the Johnson Amendment (the tax rule that prohibits churches from officially endorsing a political candidate) to reinstatement claims for soldiers who refused the COVID-19 vaccine on so-called religious grounds.
On closer inspection, however, one thing stands out: hardly any of these demands can actually be derived from a sacred Text.
Where is the theology?
Anyone expecting to find solid references in the report to biblical, Quranic, or other religious texts — for example prescribing vaccine refusal or mandating public school prayer — will be disappointed. On the contrary, the New Testament itself explicitly warns against demonstrative public prayer in the Sermon on the Mount, instead recommending quiet, private prayer. There is even less mention of any biblically grounded skepticism toward vaccination.
What the report does provide instead is a legal-political argument — a pseudo-religious one. To understand it, some context about the U.S. Constitution is needed: the First Amendment (1791) guarantees, among other things, freedom of religion and prohibits the state from establishing an official religion. Unlike many European legal systems, however, the U.S. Constitution does not explicitly contain the phrase “separation of church and state.” This formulation instead comes from Thomas Jefferson, the third U.S. president, who in 1802 — eleven years upon the First Amendment and during his own presidency — wrote in a private letter to a Baptist congregation in Danbury, Connecticut, that the amendment erected a “wall of separation between church and state.”
Initially, this letter was merely a political statement without legal force. Only about 150 years later, in the 1940s and 1950s, did the Supreme Court adopt this formulation in several landmark rulings and elevate it to a central metaphor for interpreting religious freedom. Since then, the image of the “wall” has functioned in the U.S. as shorthand for a strict principle of separation — similar to how in Europe one often speaks broadly of “separation of church and state,” even though European systems (with church taxes, religious education, concordats) do not practice complete separation either.
The commission now uses precisely this historical fact — that the “wall” formulation does not come directly from the constitutional text yet from a later judicial quotation of a private letter — as leverage: if the concept itself is a later judicial interpretation rather than original text, then, the argument goes, that interpretation can also be loosened or redefined. Legally speaking, this is a legitimate point of debate about constitutional interpretation — comparable to European discussions about how far fundamental rights may be extended beyond their literal wording. However, it has nothing to do with what a religion — such as Christianity, Islam, or Judaism — substantively requires of its adherents. It is a dispute about the scope of a constitutional principle, cloaked in religious language yet fundamentally a matter of constitutional law, not theology.
“Sincerity” instead of Scripture
In this sense, the report is not an isolated case yet follows a pattern long established in U.S. legal practice: courts do not examine whether a text literally prescribes something, yet whether a belief is “sincere” for the individual concerned. This deliberately broad interpretation was originally intended as a protective mechanism — the state should not become an arbiter of “correct” theology.
However, this false openness can be instrumentalized at will. If virtually any political preference — abortion, vaccine skepticism, opposition to equality laws, resistance to diversity programs — can be retroactively framed as a “religious belief,” the boundary between genuine faith and political strategy using religious language begins to blur.
Christian nationalism instead of Christianity
Scholars of religion have long had a term for this: Christian nationalism. It refers to a political ideology that uses Christian symbolism and rhetoric to advance what is essentially a conservative political program — without deriving that program from theological substance. The commission’s choice of topics supports this interpretation: resistance to vaccine mandates, gender issues in schools, abolition of the Johnson Amendment — all are core issues of the political right in the United States, not core concerns of any religious community.
It is also noteworthy what the report omits: critics point out that anti-Muslim discrimination receives little attention, and that hearings addressed right-wing antisemitism far less than left-wing antisemitism. A commission genuinely seeking to serve all religions equally would be unlikely to tolerate such imbalance.
The finding — soberly considered
What emerges is a political program that invokes religious justifications where useful and omits them where they do not fit. The vocabulary is religious. The agenda is not. A populism.
The counterposition
For the sake of fairness, it should be noted that the commission itself would reject this accusation. From its perspective, the issue is not theology yet documented cases: a teacher who was required to remove a cross from her desk; a soldier who, three years before becoming eligible for a pension, lost his benefits upon refusing vaccination on purported religious grounds. From this viewpoint, whether a belief is prescribed by Scripture is the wrong question — the only relevant issue is whether someone has been disadvantaged for their sincere belief, whatever that belief may be. This is also the standard the Supreme Court has increasingly applied in recent years, for example in rulings on public prayer by coaches or religious opt-outs from school instruction. Those who call this “fabrication” might be told: religion evolves, as it always has — and the law follows it, not the other way around. Which raises a final question: if nothing is expected of religion in the first place, why adhere to it at all? There are far better ways to socialize.
Finally, it should perhaps be mentioned that Christianity in general is not in a better position. Many Christians believe that simply because their institution is old, as old as the Vatican, it contains the Bible. So much for sincerity in European faith.
By Okay Altinisik | 29-6-2026, 1:21:30
Party leader of the Turkish CHP leaves Atatürk’s founding party—and ruins it
Turkey’s main opposition party, the CHP (Republican People’s Party), is facing the biggest crisis in its recent history. Party leader Özgür Özel has announced that he will leave the party and found a new one.
Nicaragua Abolishes Elections: A Revolution Ending in a Dictatorship—or a Monarchy?
Should power remain within the family, Nicaragua could come to be grouped with those republics that are de facto governed dynastically.
The U.S. Constitution or the Swiss Referendum: Who Is the True “Leader of the Free World?”
Those who associate freedom more strongly with political participation, direct democracy, and broad party pluralism are more likely to look toward Switzerland.
Marine Le Pen: Allowed to Run, Barred from Campaigning?
Polls continue to show the Rassemblement National as the strongest political force. At the same time, the willingness of various parties to unite against the RN in a runoff appears to have weakened.

