The EU Asylum Pact Takes Effect — So Who Will Still Vote Right?

Is this pact a genuine change of course? Or is it an attempt, as with the headscarf ban, to win back those voters who over the years have drifted from the center to the right — because they felt their concerns were no longer being heard?

If you vote right and were to choose a candidate, regardless of when or where they were from, who would you choose?

If you vote right and were to choose a candidate, regardless of when or where they were from, who would you choose?

On June 12, the EU asylum pact enters into force. Faster deportations at the external borders, a solidarity mechanism that forces member states to accept people or pay, and a new screening system for all arrivals. Interior Minister Gerhard Karner calls it a “major joint achievement,” Vice Chancellor Andreas Babler a “turning point away from chaos toward order.”

Whether it is that, time will tell. But what politics does not say out loud is the real political question behind the pact:

Is this pact a genuine change of course? Or is it an attempt, as with the headscarf ban, to win back those voters who over the years have drifted from the center to the right — because they felt their concerns were no longer being heard? And if it is the latter — will it work?

The FPÖ governs in Vienna. The AfD is the second-strongest force in Germany. And everywhere the same hope on the left: if the migration problem is solved, our voters will come back. Is that true?

There is one country that has already answered this question — with an experiment watched by all of Europe.

The Denmark Model: What Really Happened

Since the Danish Social Democrats under Mette Frederiksen began ideologically poaching from the right-wing populists, they have experienced a steep political rise.

That sounds like a simple success story. It is not.

Frederiksen won two elections, in 2019 and 2022, and the Social Democrats were able to win back some voters from the rural working class whom they had lost to the conservative Danish People’s Party since the 2000s. So far, so good.

But the model has a catch — and it is crucial: electoral gains on the right were neutralized by losses to parties further left. In other words: those who fish to the right lose on the left. The Social Democrats did not gain — they redistributed. And new far-right actors managed to quickly capture the existing pool of voters for themselves. Hard migration policy did not defeat the right — it split and re-sorted it.

The Real Lesson

What makes Denmark’s Social Democrats unique is the rare symbiosis of electoral success and ideological bankruptcy.

This is not left-wing polemic — it is the sober observation of a political exchange: identity for votes. And that exchange has limits. After 2022, Frederiksen abruptly changed course and opted for a broad coalition with centrist to center-right forces. Her earlier hints of economic left populism disappeared. The working-class voters who had been painstakingly brought back noticed: the party had not changed — it had only changed its language.

Why This Matters for Austria and Europe

Migration is the trigger, not the cause. Fear of loss of identity is the main factor — and it is precisely where there are hardly any foreigners that right-wing populism is strongest.

That means the EU asylum pact, faster deportations, distribution quotas — all of this addresses the symptom. The voter who moved from the SPÖ to the FPÖ does not only have a migration problem. He has a trust problem. A feeling of not being heard, which has built up over years.

Neither reducing social conflict to class questions nor a purely human-rights-oriented discourse seems to work. The center has made both mistakes for years.

The Prognosis

Some of the voters who drifted away will return — those for whom migration really was the only issue. There are fewer of them than the left hopes.

The larger share will not return — not because migration permanently pulled them to the right, but because they found something there that they had missed: the feeling that someone speaks their language.

Denmark shows: you can win back voters with hard migration policy. But you cannot defeat the right that way — you become a little right yourself. And the truly right-wing actors always find someone who goes even further.

The question is not: will they come back? The question is: where will they come back to — if the party they left is still the same?

And even if they do come back — then what?

Here lies the bitterest punchline of the whole debate. In France, the Rassemblement National holds 126 seats as the second-strongest force in parliament — and still failed to obtain a single key post. The left alliance and the center divided the positions among themselves; the cordon sanitaire held.

In Germany, the firewall against the AfD still stands — despite more than 20 percent of the vote. In Austria, by contrast, the cordon sanitaire toward the FPÖ was permeable from the start and finally collapsed with the first ÖVP-FPÖ coalition in 2000.

The result of these two strategies is revealing. The actual balance sheet of the firewall is weak. It is true that the RN, AfD, and Vlaams Belang have so far not entered government — but that is only cold comfort: all three have built firm roots in the electorate and are likely to remain for a long time.

And this brings us back to the real question: whether voters return or not — the established parties have a structural problem that no asylum pact solves. By adopting the right’s arguments, mainstream parties ultimately normalize its program.

In other words: those who copy the right help it grow. Those who exclude it make it stronger.

By Okay Altinisik | 5-6-2026, 10:38:52

Party leader of the Turkish CHP leaves Atatürk’s founding party—and ruins it

Turkey’s main opposition party, the CHP (Republican People’s Party), is facing the biggest crisis in its recent history. Party leader Özgür Özel has announced that he will leave the party and found a new one.

Nicaragua Abolishes Elections: A Revolution Ending in a Dictatorship—or a Monarchy?

Should power remain within the family, Nicaragua could come to be grouped with those republics that are de facto governed dynastically.

The U.S. Constitution or the Swiss Referendum: Who Is the True “Leader of the Free World?”

Those who associate freedom more strongly with political participation, direct democracy, and broad party pluralism are more likely to look toward Switzerland.

Marine Le Pen: Allowed to Run, Barred from Campaigning?

Polls continue to show the Rassemblement National as the strongest political force. At the same time, the willingness of various parties to unite against the RN in a runoff appears to have weakened.

Leave a Reply